No items found.

Guide to Uncovering Environmental Violations With Data

Written by

Environmental violations often represent some of the most egregious breaches of public trust and safety, manifesting insignificant harm to ecosystems and human health. These infractions, whether they involve illegal dumping of hazardous waste, unlawful emissions of toxic pollutants, or the contamination of water sources, pose serious risks.

The consequences are far-reaching, affecting not only the immediate environment but also the long-term well-being of communities. As plaintiffs' attorneys, recognizing the gravity of these violations is crucial. It is your duty to hold those responsible accountable, ensuring that the legal system serves as a deterrent against future misconduct. Data and advanced technologies are an essential part in enabling attorneys to proactively identify environmental violations, hold responsible parties accountable, and bring justice to those who deserve it.

Additionally, systemic inequities mean that these communities frequently feel disenfranchised and voiceless, believing they lack the power or means to seek legal redress. This sense of helplessness is exacerbated by the complexities of environmental law and the often subtle, cumulative nature of environmental harm, making it difficult for individuals to connect their health problems directly to local industrial activities.

However, it is possible to be proactive in identifying environmental violations and addressing them before they become widespread.

Robust datasets and advanced technologies empower attorneys to identify and address environmental violations with precision and efficiency. By leveraging comprehensive data and cutting-edge tools, plaintiffs' attorneys can monitor and investigate potential infractions more effectively.

These technologies enable the early detection of violations, allowing for timely intervention before issues escalate. This approach not only safeguards vulnerable communities but also supports the preservation of our environment for future generations. In this guide, we explore the human health impacts of environmental violations and the innovative strategies attorneys can employ to address them.

Data is your friend

Data is essential in environmental law, as it provides the concrete evidence needed to substantiate claims of environmental violations. By analyzing data, attorneys can identify patterns and trends that indicate non-compliance with environmental regulations. This includes monitoring pollutant levels, observing occurrences of known negative impacts from contaminants, and reviewing historical data from government agencies and independent environmental monitoring organizations.

Utilizing data not only strengthens the validity of a claim but also enables attorneys to build a compelling narrative to establish causation that can persuade courts and regulatory bodies.

Large datasets allow for more robust statistical analysis, making it possible to detect even subtle signs of environmental violations at early stages.With a comprehensive dataset, attorneys can compare environmental conditions over time and across different locations, thereby identifying anomalies and potential breaches of regulations before they become widespread and cause a lot of harm.

In essence, the more data attorneys can gather and analyze, the more compelling and credible their claims will be, significantly enhancing their chances of success in environmental litigation. In the United States, numerous public data sources are available to gather evidence for environmental violations, including government databases and public health records.

However, these sources are dispersed and highly localized, with no single entity providing comprehensive health or pollution data at the federal or state level. This fragmentation necessitates mapping various data sources across states, presenting a significant challenge in utilizing the data effectively.

Identifying the right data sources

To proactively identify environmental violations, plaintiffs' attorneys must remain informed about ongoing environmental news and litigation. Monitoring these sources can provide valuable insights and leads for potential cases. When a contaminant appears to be causing harm, there are a number of steps attorneys can take in order to identify the relevant datasources to build a case:

1) Conduct legal research

The first step is conducting thorough legal research to formalize the legal elements needed fora successful case. To do this, attorneys should examine previous successful cases related to the specific chemical in order to understand the types of information and evidence required to build a robust case.

Advanced technologies and large language models (LLMs) exist that are able to streamline and speed up this process.

2) Identify characteristics of the contaminant

Following the initial research, attorneys need to identify the specific characteristics related to the contaminant they are investigating. For example, it is important to understand how the contaminant spreads (is this by air, by water or by another means), in addition to the specific or most prominent side effects related to the contaminant. Defining these characteristics will allow attorneys to understand the types of data sources they need to look for, in order to collect the evidence to make a strong case.

It is also important to understand the legal implications of the contaminant. For example, a chemical that is not recognized by courts as one that can cause harm might require attorneys to allocate additional resources to gather scientific studies and experts to support its risk.

Alternatively, it might indicate at an early stage that the case is unlikely to be successful, and not worth taking on. In contrast, a chemical with a well-known legal status, such as PFAS or Glyphosate, would not need the same effort from the attorney, thus changing the strategy for the case.

3) Map the data source

Attorneys now need to strategically map out the necessary data sources to support their case. It is important to remember that there are typically numerous sources with relevant information rather than a single definitive source. Be mindful of this, and map out as many sources as you can find, to gather as much data as possible, in order to build a strong and successful case.

If a chemical spreads through the air, attorneys need to locate the appropriate databases that collect air sample data, in addition to identifying health data related to the specific side effects caused by the chemical. Public forums and social media platforms can also be invaluable, as they may reveal patterns of potential causation between chemical exposure and health impacts. Moreover, reviewing information published by specific regulators who monitor the chemical in question can provide authoritative data and potentially support the case further.

In addition, using the most localized data sets ensures accurate information for specific geographical areas. This is particularly important in the environmental domain, where toxic tort violations are closely tied to spatial factors.

4) Understand the infrastructure of the data sources

It is important to understand the underlying infrastructure of the databases you are using, as this affects the strength of the data points that will be used as evidence in court. And perhaps most importantly, data quality measures are another aspect of data sources that is vital to comprehend. Attorneys must understand the validation, cleaning, and maintenance processes for each data source.

Environmental law cases often hinge on the reliability of scientific data, so knowing these measures, and being able to prove the legitimacy of the evidence is essential to the success of a case.Attorneys should start by identifying the update frequency of each environmental database, and understand how often data is updated in each of the data sources.

For example, Is air quality data refreshed hourly, are water quality reports updated weekly, or are endangered species populations tracked annually? This knowledge directly impacts the strength and relevance of the data points in legal proceedings. For instance, real-time pollution monitoring data carries a different weight to annual biodiversity assessments.It is also essential to pay close attention to the parameters of each data set, as the units of measurement can vary significantly, depending on the data at hand. A thorough understanding of each data set's details is crucial, as misunderstanding these could lead to errors in your environmental impact analysis.

Making sense of huge amounts of data

Organizing and analyzing the large amounts of data needed to build strong environmental cases can be intimidating due to the sheer volume and complexity of the data, requiring sophisticated tools and methodologies to manage and process it effectively. For modern attorneys, there are technologies available to aid in doing exactly this.

Geographic information systems

Geographic information systems (GIS) are specialized software applications designed to capture, store, manipulate, analyze, manage, and present spatial or geographic data.These tools are essential for lawyers aiming to proactively identify and address environmental violations.

When environmental data is downloaded, it often comes in massive spreadsheets filled with a plethora of information, not all of which is relevant to every investigation. Sifting through these files to find pertinent data can be overwhelming and time-consuming. In addition, when dealing with such large amounts of data, it is extremely difficult to digest thousands of rows and columns in spreadsheets without visualizing the different data points, making it nearly impossible to connect dots and see the overarching patterns that emerge from the data. This is where Geographic information systems come into play. They enable the importing and organization of this raw data spatially on a map, making it easier to discern meaningful patterns and correlations.

Creating multi-layered maps

One of the most powerful features of Geographic information systems is their ability to create maps with multiple layers. These layers can represent different types of data, such as:

Sources of pollution: This includes data on facility emissions and application records, showing where contaminants are being produced.
Environmental presence data: This data can be from air and water samples indicating where the contaminant is present in the environment.
Public comments: Information about complaints related to health side effects associated with the contaminant.

By overlaying these different data sets, the resulting map provides a comprehensive view of the environmental landscape. For example, attorneys can see not only where a contaminant is being emitted but also where it is being detected in the environment and where residents are reporting adverse health effects.

Identifying areas for further investigation

The maps generated by Geographic information systems do more than just display data; they allow for analysis of the volume and distribution of data points in each area. This capability is crucial for attorneys who need to pinpoint specific areas for further investigation. By identifying overlaps in data layers—such as areas with high levels of environmental contaminants and numerous related health complaints—lawyers can efficiently target their efforts. This spatial analysis enables a more proactive approach to environmental law. Instead of reacting to individual complaints or isolated data points, attorneys can identify and investigate hotspots where violations are most likely occurring. This proactive stance is essential for protecting public health and the environment effectively.

Large Language models (LLMs)

A Large Language Model (LLM) is an advanced type of artificial intelligence (AI) that processes and understands human language. It’s trained on vast amounts of text data, enabling it to generate, analyze, and aggregate information from unstructured text.

Unlike traditional keyword search methods, which rely on exact matches of specific terms, LLMs can be used to embed information and make it semantically searchable, allowing users to perform concept searches. Essentially, LLMs can understand the context and meaning behind words and phrases, even if they are misspelled or presented in varied formats, whereas traditional keyword searches require needing to know exactly what symptoms or side effects you are looking for in the text.

LLMs are able to find patterns of different damages, and may even reveal a type of damage you were not aware of. The way this works is that the LLM finds recurring patterns in language, and recognizes certain patterns as damages, without searching for specific types of damages.Incorporating Large Language Models into the data analysis toolkit empowers attorneys to efficiently organize and make sense of unstructured data. By transforming scattered data into structured insights, LLMs enable proactive identification of environmental violations.

Uncovering insights from community complaints

Imagine a scenario where the data you have collected involves numerous letters from the local population, complaining about side effects from environmental contaminants. Not only will you need such a large volume of letters (thousands or more) in order to build a strong case, but these letters will be diverse in format, language, and content, making it challenging to extract actionable insights through manual analysis or simple keyword searches.This is where LLMs excel. They can read through all the letters, identify and categorize the symptoms mentioned, assess their severity, and even pinpoint the geo-locations referred to in the complaints.

From unstructured text to organized data Large Language Models (LLMs) are extremely good at uncovering patterns, phenomena, and narratives within unstructured text. They achieve this by understanding the essential elements that constitute a story, extracting these elements, and categorizing them effectively. For instance, LLMs can identify a recurring pattern where individuals across the UnitedStates are affected by the same contaminant and exhibit the same side effects, potentially even tracing these issues back to the same company.

From unstructured text to organized data

Large Language Models (LLMs) are extremely good at uncovering patterns, phenomena, and narratives within unstructured text. They achieve this by understanding the essential elements that constitute a story, extracting these elements, and categorizing them effectively. For instance, LLMs can identify a recurring pattern where individuals across the UnitedStates are affected by the same contaminant and exhibit the same side effects, potentially even tracing these issues back to the same company.

This capability transforms vast amounts of unstructured text into organized, actionable data, enabling deeper insights and more informed decision-making. For instance, LLMs can categorize letters based on:

Symptoms: Identifying specific health issues mentioned, such as coughing, headaches, or nausea. With LLMs you can even look for more general“respiratory symptoms” and the model will know which specific symptoms to look for.
Severity: Assessing the intensity or frequency of the reported symptoms.
Geo-location: Extracting location information from the text and enhancing it with implied geographic data.

Once the LLM has organized the data, it can identify fact patterns by analyzing not only similar symptoms but also similar fact patterns. For example it can identify the same or similar side effects, from the same or similar exposures, from contaminants produced or sold by the same or similar companies.

By examining these connections, LLMs can even correlate different scenarios, linking symptoms with the known use of specific substances in particular areas.This capability allows for a more nuanced understanding of how various factors interrelate.

Beyond statistics: validating correlations

While traditional data analysis relies heavily on statistics, LLMs offer a deeper validation of patterns and correlations. By understanding the context in which symptoms are mentioned and linking them to specific locations, LLMs help validate whether observed correlations between contaminants and health issues are meaningful. Together with all the statistical information collected, this capability is crucial for strengthening the causation argument in order to build robust cases in environmental law.

Conclusion

There is immense potential for identifying and addressing environmental violations from the vast amounts of publicly available data.

However, the key lies in effectively mapping the right data sources and organizing this information in a meaningful way. Advanced technologies such as GeographicInformation Systems (GIS) and Large Language Models (LLMs) offer powerful tools to overcome these challenges, enabling attorneys to analyze complex datasets, uncover hidden patterns, and generate actionable insights.

By embracing these technological advancements, attorneys can proactively identify environmental violations, ensure compliance, and advocate for better environmental practices. The integration of data-driven strategies not only enhances the efficiency and accuracy of legal work but also strengthens the capacity to protect our environment, and the health of many communities.

Work with us to find your next environmental case.

‍

________________________

This might interest you:‍